Head-to-head comparison
PlanetBox Rover vs Bentgo Kids
The two lunch boxes NYC parents debate most.
The two lunch boxes NYC parents debate most. One is premium stainless steel that lasts forever. The other is affordable plastic that does the job. Both are excellent — the question is your priorities.
Option A
PlanetBox Rover
$55
Pros
✓18/8 stainless steel — no plastic touching food
✓Dishwasher safe, lasts 10+ years
✓5 compartments, great portions
✓Fun magnets for decorating the lid
✓Eco-friendly, no waste
Cons
✗NOT leak-proof without silicone cups ($15 extra)
✗Heavy — noticeable in a small backpack
✗Expensive upfront
✗Compartments are fixed — can't adjust sizes
✗Metal dents if dropped (cosmetic only)
Option B
Bentgo Kids
$28
Pros
✓Actually leak-proof — yogurt, applesauce, dips all safe
✓Lightweight — barely adds weight to backpack
✓5 compartments with removable divider
✓Affordable — can buy 2 (one for school, one for backup)
✓BPA-free, CPSC safety tested
Cons
✗Plastic — even BPA-free, some parents prefer to avoid
✗Stains from tomato sauce, turmeric
✗Latch can be hard for 3-year-olds to open
✗Replace every 2-3 years (plastic wears)
✗Not dishwasher safe on bottom rack
The verdict
So which one should you get?
PlanetBox if you want to avoid plastic entirely and don't mind the weight/price. Bentgo if you want leak-proof, lightweight, and affordable. Most NYC classrooms have a mix of both.
Get the PlanetBox Rover if:
Get PlanetBox if avoiding plastic is a priority and you'll invest in the silicone cups for leak-proofing.
View PlanetBox Rover →Get the Bentgo Kids if:
Get Bentgo if you want leak-proof convenience, lighter weight, and lower cost.
View Bentgo Kids →Affiliate disclosure: Product links go to Amazon. We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.