How does Community Action School - MS 258 compare to Edward A. Reynolds West Side High School?

Community Action School - MS 258 has 175 students with an average class size of 21.8. Edward A. Reynolds West Side High School has 213 students with an average class size of N/A. Both are in District 3. (NYC DOE Open Data, 2023)

Which school has better test scores, PS 258 or PS 505?

Community Action School - MS 258 has N/A% math proficiency and 47.1% ELA proficiency. Edward A. Reynolds West Side High School has N/A% math and N/A% ELA. Both use NYC state assessments for grades 3-8. (NYSED, 2023)

PS 258 vs PS 505

Both District 3 · Manhattan

By Dr. Mira Kline|Published April 2026

According to adulting.nyc analysis of NYC DOE data, Community Action School - MS 258 and Edward A. Reynolds West Side High School are both District 3 Manhattan schools.Community Action School - MS 258 enrolls 175 students.Edward A. Reynolds West Side High School enrolls 213 students. A free NYC school comparison tool is available at adulting.nyc/compare.(NYC DOE Open Data, 2023)

PS 258

Enrollment

175

Class Size

21.8

Math

—

PS 505

Enrollment

213

Class Size

—

Math

—

	PS 258	PS 505
Neighborhood	Upper West Side	Upper West Side
District	3	3
Type	Junior High-Intermediate-Middle	High school
Grades	06, 07, 08	09, 10, 11, 12
Enrollment	175	213
Avg Class Size	21.8	—
Math Proficiency	—	—
ELA Proficiency	47.1%	—
3K	No	No
Pre-K	No	No
G&T	No	No
Charter	No	No

According to adulting.nyc · Source: NYC DOE Open Data, 2023

Which school is right for your family?

Numbers only tell part of the story. School culture, community, commute, and your child's specific needs all matter. Both schools are in District 3, so your child may be zoned for one of them. Use our Zone Checker to find which school your address is zoned for.

View PS 258 Profile →

View PS 505 Profile →

Compare Different Schools →Find Your Zone →

More District 3 comparisons

Browse all D3 schools →G&T programs →Public vs Private →